Both the radio and television shows drew as much attention from professional educators as from radio and television fans, viewers, and critics. In addition to the 1948–49 poll of
Radio Mirror listeners and the 1949 poll of
Motion Picture Daily critics, Arden's notices soon expanded beyond her media. According to the
Museum of Broadcast Communications, she was made an honorary member of the
National Education Association and received a 1952 award from the Teachers College of Connecticut's Alumni Association "for humanizing the American teacher".
Our Miss Brooks was considered groundbreaking for showing a woman who was neither a scatterbrained klutz nor a homebody, but rather a working woman who transcended the actual or assumed limits to women's working lives of the time. Connie Brooks was considered a realistic character in an unglamorized profession (she often joked, for example, about being underpaid, as many teachers are), and who showed women could be competent and self-sufficient outside their home lives without losing their femininity or their humanity.
Our Miss Brooks remained Eve Arden's most identifiable and popular role, with numerous surviving recordings of both the radio and television versions continuing to entertain listeners and viewers. (The surviving radio recordings include both its audition shows.) A quarter century after the show ended, Arden told radio historian
John Dunning in an on-air interview just what the show and the role came to mean to her: I originally loved the theater. I still do. And I had always wanted to have a hit on Broadway that was created by me. You know, kind of like
Judy Holliday and
Born Yesterday. I griped about it a little, and someone said to me, "Do you realize that if you had a hit on Broadway, probably 100 or 200,000 people might have seen you in it, if you'd stayed in it long enough. And this way, you've been in
Miss Brooks, everybody loves you, and you've been seen by millions." So, I figured I'd better shut up while I was ahead.
Television cast •
Eve Arden as Connie Brooks •
Gale Gordon as Osgood Conklin •
Robert Rockwell as Phillip Boynton •
Jane Morgan as Margaret Davis •
Jesslyn Fax as Margaret Davis's sister, Angela Devon •
Richard Crenna as Walter Denton •
Gloria McMillan as Harriet Conklin •
Isabel Randolph as Ruth Nestor, principal of Miss Brooks' new school beginning in "Big Ears" (November 4, 1955). •
Joseph Kearns as Superintendent Stone (eight episodes) •
William Ching as Clint Allbright (four episodes) •
Gene Barry as Gene Talbot •
Orangey as Minerva the cat ==List of television episodes==