On the original publication of the novel a reviewer in Brisbane's
The Telegraph placed the book in its literary context by stating: "In this book the influence of
Marcus Clarke is apparent, and although the narrative is smoother, it is not less brilliant and fascinating." In a review of the first 6 winners of the ALS Gold Medal, "J.K.E." in
The West Australian noted that "The characterisation is vivid and the writer has the power of making us feel the reality of her people." The reviewer for
The Morning Post of London said: "Fine, virile, and graphic in style, spacious in atmosphere and treatment, this history of the early settlers and old convict days in Tasmania further gives us two of the most exquisite feminine portraits that I have seen in a novel for a long time." By the 1990s, however, the view of the book had changed with
The Oxford Companion to Australian Literature stating: "The novel's attempts to present Tasmanian history as a colourful pageant result in woodenness and contrived efforts, although some of the characters have vitality." ==Awards and nominations==