Owner Leo Brill, a former pizza chef at
Oven and Shaker, started the business as a backyard
pop-up restaurant in the summer of 2020. In January 2022, Bill announced plans to operate the business from a
food cart on Alberta Street in northeast Portland. The cart opened on March 4, 2022. Brill has donated business proceeds to various nonprofit organizations and other groups, including
Don't Shoot PDX, For The Gworls,
Minnesota Freedom Fund, the
National Black Justice Coalition, and
The Okra Project. Flynn McEchron is a business partner. For Pizza Week in 2024, Paladin Pie served the special Questing Taco pizza, which had vegetarian chili, cheddar, mozzarella,
jalapeño crema,
scallion, and
Fritos. Paladin Pie's "sibling" restaurant Oathbreaker Pie opened in the
Hinterland Bar and Food Carts in November 2024. == Reception ==