Garcia-Lee made her Broadway debut at the age of 17 in a production of
The Phantom of the Opera in 2008. Other theatre credits include
Nice Work If You Can Get It,
On the Town,
Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812,
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and
Moulin Rouge!. She would also be announced to be playing Graziella again in the
Steven Spielberg theatrical film version of
West Side Story. Garcia-Lee lobbied for the role, based on hers and her mother's histories with the musical. She auditioned in the fall of 2018, and secured the role in November. Garcia-Lee had previously been in contention for the role when the musical was revived in 2009, and would also decline offers to play the characters Mugsy and Anybodys in other productions in favor of playing Graziella. which premiered at the 2023
South by Southwest festival. In 2024, she would appear in episodes of the television shows
Elsbeth,
Doctor Odyssey and
Star Wars: Skeleton Crew, as well as performed in a production of
Nine at the
Kennedy Center that August. ==Personal life==