Early history of Pallimnarchus Although only named in 2020,
Paludirex has a long and rich history thanks to its ties to the historic genus
Pallimnarchus.
Pallimnarchus pollens was informally described in 1886 by
Charles Walter De Vis, who based the genus on skull remains and osteoderms discovered around 1860 that was mineralised by
apatite. De Vis' collection lacked cohesion and not only consisted of material that belonged to different individuals, but even to different species, as one bone was later proven to have belonged to a species of
Quinkana. Their exact origin is likewise not well recorded by De Vis, with the type locality of the remains being unknown beyond the fact that they stem from the
Darling Downs region of
Queensland. While the nomenclature used by Sill was incorrect, this would not be the only time a link between
Pallimnarchus and the genus
Crocodylus was made. In 1982 Australian paleontologist
Ralph Molnar proposed that the "Lansdowne Snout" actually belonged to a
saltwater crocodile,
Revisions and second species Molnar however did not follow through on that, instead publishing a formal redescription of
Pallimnarchus later that same year. Molnar tentatively accepted the validity of
Pallimnarchus as a genus but recognized the highly flawed nature of De Vis' work. Given the fact that De Vis' material consisted of fragmentary remains of multiple individuals, Molnar established a
lectotype, the anterior portion of a lower jaw (specimen QMF1149) that was part of De Vis' original collection. Beyond being labeled as the holotype in collections already, this immature specimen was chosen as it was significantly more complete than the other material the genus had previously been based on. However, Molnar's description was still limited in comparison, with only four other Australasian crocodilians being known at the time: the
saltwater crocodile,
freshwater crocodile,
New Guinea crocodile and
Quinkana.
Paludirex Things once again fell silent around
Pallimnarchus during the 2000s, with publications on this genus only appearing occasionally. This was not helped by the fact that Molnar's lectotype was lost following his initial redescription, with Jorgo Ristevski and colleagues suspecting that the material disappeared sometime during the late 90s or early 2000s. The fate and current whereabouts of the lectotype are unknown and even a thorough search of the collection of the
Queensland Museum in 2004 only yielded a singular, non-diagnostic fragment of said specimen with the remainder of the mandible nowhere to be found. This means that the only source for information on the lectotype are the illustrations and photographs provided by Molnar in the 1982 paper. In 2008, "Geoff Vincent's specimen" was returned to Dot Vincent, the wife of the late Geoff Vincent, who subsequently donated it to the
Chinchilla Museum. In the process one skull fragment was accidentally left behind in
Brisbane, which led to different parts of the skull now having different specimen numbers. By then it had become clear that
Pallimnarchus had once again entered taxonomic limbo in spite of the previous efforts by Willis and Molnar, as the attempts at redefining the genus were insufficient to differentiate it from the surge of new mekosuchines and the lectotype itself disappeared. Ristevski
et al. published a third and final revision of the genus in 2020, declaring it dubious based on the fact that no distinguishing features could be found in the small piece of the lectotype that still remained. The team, which included Ralph Molnar, instead established a new name for the material previously assigned to
Pallimnarchus. The result of their work was
Paludirex vincenti, a taxon not based on mandibular remains as
Pallimnarchus was but based on the skull fragments that compose "Geoff Vincent's specimen". While this decision finally established a well preserved
holotype and provided a detailed diagnosis, it also meant that the vast quantity of material previously assigned to
Pallimnarchus had to be reevaluated, with mixed results. Some specimens, notably those that preserve elements of the cranium, could confidently be assigned to the newly erected genus. A premaxilla and maxilla found near the Condamine River near
Warra were attributued to
Paludirex vincenti and the "Mirani Shire skull" could at least be tentatively assigned to the species. Additionally, the "Lansdowne Snout" was referred to P. vincenti three years later. Furthermore, the validity of the material previously dubbed
Pallimnarchus gracilis was confirmed, creating the new combination
Paludirex gracilis. However,
Paludirex gracilis was now restricted to the type material, the premaxilla and the associated dentary fragment. The switch to "Geoff Vincent's specimen" as the holotype did have one big drawback, which is that the specimen has no associated mandibular remains. This means that the only lower jaw remains currently referable to
Paludirex are those directly associated with the premaxilla of
P. gracilis, meaning that the validity of many of the mandibles previously referred to Palimnarchus is up in the air. Although it is deemed likely that some, although not all, of these lower jaws did belong to
Paludirex, they cannot be confidently assigned to the new genus until fossils are found that preserve both the upper and lower jaws in association with one another. Until such a fossil is found, these remains can only be identified as Crocodilia indet. and nothing more specific. Ristevski and his team further highlight various possible scenarios for the future of
Pallimnarchus. Should the lectotype be rediscovered, there is the possibility that
Paludirex may eventually become a
junior synonym of
Pallimnarchus. At the same time, it is just as likely that future research finds the two to be different animals altogether, as the presence of multiple broad-snouted crocodilians in the Pliocene of Australia is not only possible but very likely. However, both of these possible scenarios hinge on the lectotype being rediscovered, it preserving previously unrecognized diagnostic features and finally for there to be sufficient overlapping material of other crocodilians to compare it to. Until then,
Pallimnarchus is treated as a
nomen dubium and
Paludirex as valid and distinct taxon.
Etymology Paludirex is derived from the Latin words "paludis" and "rex", translating to "swamp king". This
etymology was deliberately chosen to maintain a connection with its predecessor, as it serves as a rough equivalent to the etymology of
Pallimnarchus, whose name translated to "ruler of all swamps". ==Species==