Panthalassa received positive reviews from critics.
The Wire called it an "ambient fusion power force which breathed new life into the originals without detracting from Davis's artistic intentions", crediting Laswell for "teasing out the music's spiritual dimension". Joshua Klein of
The A.V. Club said the reordered songs did not "sound out of context" and commended Laswell for giving more exposure to these unappreciated "masterpieces".
Robert Christgau declared he would play the album as often as the electric-period Davis records
In a Silent Way and
Jack Johnson (1971). He wrote in
The Village Voice that listeners unfamiliar with Davis' fusion albums will find it to be "a passport to provisional utopia" in
Panthalassa: In a year-end list for the
Pazz & Jop critics poll, Christgau named
Panthalassa the sixth best record of 1998. When first hearing "Shhh/Peaceful" on
Panthalassa,
Geoff Dyer said he realized the impact such compositions had on ambient and
chill-out music. == Track listing ==