Peter Shields formed a new version of Simon Caine (dropping The Catch) in October 1969 with original members Bill Palmer, John Savage and Dennis Pendrith, who had spent the interim playing with
Olivus,
3's a Crowd, and
Ugly Ducklings spin-off group, GNU. The new members were pianist Pat Godfrey (born 1948 in Toronto) from The Diplomats and wind instrumentalist Bruce Pennycook (born October 5, 1949, in Toronto). The new line up signed to RCA Victor and issued a lone single, "Walked Out The Door", written by Pat Godfrey and Dave Richardson, which coincided with an appearance at Toronto's Electric Circus (December 12–14, 1969). The following year, the group gigged intensively throughout southern Ontario and also completed sessions for an album at RCA Recording Studios in Toronto with producer George Semkiw, which was released in October 1970. That same month, the band returned to Toronto's live scene with a show at the Night Owl, followed by an appearance at Ryerson Great Hall alongside
Leigh Ashford on November 6, 1970. Simon Caine should have seen the new year in at Toronto's Maple Leaf Gardens, appearing at a prestigious show that also featured
Johnny Winter,
Rare Earth,
Poco,
The James Gang, and fellow Canadians
Chilliwack, but a disagreement over the fee meant that the band didn't appear. Despite a positive write-up in the Toronto Telegram in its October 1 issue, the album didn't sell well. The group started work on a new album in early 1971 with another producer but broke up before the sessions were completed. ==Aftermath==