The building is located on the site of pioneer Omaha's magnificent
Grand Central Hotel, which burnt down in 1878. Brothers C.W., W.T. and J.B. Kitchen built the original Paxton Hotel in 1882 to replace it, spending $250,000. The building contained 175 rooms, including an elegant dining room and a bar. The Kitchen Brothers ran several hotels throughout the
Western United States, with one operating the Thornburg House in
Laramie City, the Maxwell House at
Rawlins, the Desert House in
Green River and the Mountain Trout House at
Evanston, all in the
Wyoming Territory. Another ran the Pacific Hotel in
St. Joseph, Missouri and the third operated the Paxton, as well as the Withnell House in Omaha. The Omaha building was named the Paxton after
William A. Paxton, an Omaha pioneer who lived at the hotel soon after it was built. He reportedly donated five thousand dollars to add a fifth story to the structure. Other notable residents included General
George Crook, as well as prominent Omaha families including the
J. L. Brandeises and Emil Brandeis, the Baums, the Wilhelms, and the Hanscoms.
Woodmen of the World was founded at the hotel in 1890. The hotel was the site of one of Omaha's grand
"live" signs of the day, which was a
Krug Brewing Company advertisement featuring a wide by tall
beer stein with a
Luxus logo. In the early 1900s the hotel was the site of the murder of Harry King, a son of the millionaire owner of Browning, King & Co. men's apparel store in Omaha. King's mistress, Elizabeth Bechler, fired two shots at him as he walked away from her in the hotel lobby. William Jennings Bryan addressed Omaha's Jacksononian Club at the hotel in 1900, and stayed there for several nights. That same year the hotel hosted
Maud Gonne, an
Irish revolutionary, feminist and actress. President McKinley was a guest during the
Trans-Mississippi and International Exposition in 1898. In the
United States presidential election of 1912 the Paxton housed the
Progressive,
Democratic and
Republican parties, with dignitaries including Presidents
Woodrow Wilson and
Theodore Roosevelt registering as guests. Other steady customers were Buffalo Bill and prizefighter
Bob Fitzsimmons. The original building was demolished in 1927. ==Current building==