In the decade following Tillman's retirement, the rate of forced fumbles increased as other players began employing the Peanut Punch. Cornerbacks were especially responsible for the uptick in what Silverstein called a "cornerback forced fumble revolution", with seven cornerbacks finishing top five in fumbles forced from 2020 to 2022 whereas the ten-year stretch between 1999 and 2009 had just ten combined. Through the late 2010s and 2020s, coaches encouraged their defenses to punch at the ball when they could. Smith recalled he had to disregard traditional tackling methods to train himself to punch at the ball, calling it "a minus" if a defender cannot do so.
Ron Rivera, who was Tillman's defensive coordinator in Chicago and head coach in Carolina, had his players target the ball carrier's
pressure points where his arm is gripping the ball and punch at the exposed locations. Former Lions coach
Matt Patricia's defense practiced a variation called "CPR"—"club, punch, rip"—in which a defender identified how the carrier was holding the ball, punched at it, or tried to yank it out. Ahead of the
2024–25 NFL playoffs,
Philadelphia Eagles head coach
Nick Sirianni emphasized the tactic by requiring his defense and staff to review Tillman's film; the Eagles successfully executed three Peanut Punches in the postseason and went on to win
Super Bowl LIX. In the closing stretch of the
2022 NFL season, the league sent a training video to all general managers and head coaches that properly defined the Peanut Punch as a football concept and move. NFL officials also provided guidance on timing the move so that it is not interpreted as punching an opponent after the play. Another memo was released by the NFL in cautioning defenders to ensure they are punching at the ball and not opposing players. The 2015 video game
Madden NFL 16 had a trophy called "Peanut Punch" for a successful forced fumble. ==See also==