Less than a week after the shooting, police arrested six other students, charging them with conspiracy to commit murder. Justin Sledge had gone on a local news report and read from the notebooks of writings given to him just before the shooting. During the summer of 1997, the supposed members of the Kroth allegedly made plans to terrorize Pearl High School. The plans ultimately involved Woodham entering the school and opening fire. Days after the arrest, an antagonistic note claiming to be written by “The Alliance of the Immortalz“ was pinned to a memorial near the school sign. Justin Sledge denied any involvement in the act as well as any knowledge of, or connection to, “the Kroth” or the “Alliance of the Immortalz.” Regardless, Sledge was widely blamed for the act. Following the shooting, Sledge spoke at a prayer vigil held to mourn the dead students, for which he received a suspension from the school district. Sledge says his comments at the memorial were mischaracterized but still "clearly inappropriate". On October 8, 1997, Sledge, Boyette, and the others were arrested on suspicion of
conspiring with Woodham to commit the shooting. Woodham claimed that Boyette had told him he had "potential to do something great," and promised him that he could get his ex-girlfriend back through
black magic. Sledge, who is now an academic specializing in philosophy and religion, argues that the media and police's claims that he was part of a satanic cult lacked evidence, exemplifying the broader
Satanic Panic trend of the 1980s and 1990s. After his conviction Woodham converted to
Christianity, and said the following in a letter written to
evangelical minister
David Wilkerson: ==Trials and incarceration==