Archeological evidence of Native American communities, including the
Shinnecock Indian Nation, harvesting scallops in the Peconic Bays is robust. Large numbers of scallop shells have been discovered on locations around eastern Long Island, including
Robins Island,
Shelter Island, and
Orient. Beginning in the 1870s, the northern bay scallop fishery was an engine of economic growth in communities on and around the Peconic Bays, as well as other coastal communities along the
eastern seaboard of the United States. For the following century, Peconic Bay scallops were an important part of the economy, particularly in the winter when other business activity decreased; Peconic Bay scallops are considered the "jewel" of eastern Long Island’s recreational and commercial fishery. In February 1900, thousands of bushels of scallops washed up onto the shores of Peconic Bay. The U.S.
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration declared the collapse of the Long Island scallop fishery a federal disaster in 2021. The value of commercially-fished scallops, after reaching a high of 1.5 million USD in 2018, dropped to 61,000 USD in 2021. Scallops in nearby
Moriches Bay, however, have experienced an upsurge in numbers. There have been proposals to transplant some Moriches Bay scallops to Peconic Bay as a test to determine if Moriches Bay scallops are more resilient to stress caused by warming waters and parasites than the Peconic Bay scallop population. == Conservation ==