The New York Times wrote, "with superb acting, photography that is effective and unusual, yet not bizarre, and direction that is gentleness and good taste itself,
Peg of Old Drury is one of the finest cinema production ever to come out of England, or of anywhere else, for that matter"; while
TV Guide wrote, "Neagle and Hardwicke give impressive performances, and the excerpts from
Shakespeare and
Jonson are flawlessly mounted. Much of the film's power derives from the screenplay by actor
Malleson in his first screenwriting assignment."
Graham Greene, writing for
The Spectator, gave a more mixed review suggesting that there is "no historical truth to be found anywhere in the deft, neat tale". Greene remarked on the attractiveness of Neagle and found that the film was "very pretty", but concluded that "prettiness is a quality one wants, if at all, in small quantities". ==References==