Pelham Edgar was a member of the
Athenaeum Club, London, England. Edgar was president of the Tennyson Club, Toronto, and president of the Modern Language Association, Ontario. He was secretary of the Ontario Education Society from 1908 to 1909. In 1915 he became a Fellow of the
Royal Society of Canada. In 1936 he received the Royal Society's
Lorne Pierce Medal for distinguished service to Canadian literature. A description of Edgar around 1926 said, "He was then in his middle fifties, tall and spare, with piercing dark eyes under thick eyebrows and a wealth of lustrous black hair. His aquiline nose surmounted the largest black mustache I had ever seen – it was difficult not to stare at in fascination." Pelham Edgar was secretary of the Canadian Society of Authors. He was among the founders of the
Canadian Authors Association, which first met on 12 March 1921 in the Old Medical Building of
McGill University. In April he met with members of the recently formed Canadian Society of Authors to present the more ambitious program of the Canadian Authors Association. The Society decided to retain its charter, but hoped to find a way to merge with the Association's Toronto branch. In 1935 he became ninth national president of the Canadian Authors Association. In 1936 Edgar launched the
Canadian Poetry Magazine, and also initiated the Governor General's Awards. He became the first president of the Association of Canadian Bookmen in 1936, an organization dedicated to supporting the booksellers and distributors in Canada. The Bookmen organized their first National Book Fair in Toronto in the fall of 1936 in the
King Edward Hotel, Toronto. In 1931 Edgar created the Canadian Authors Foundation to provide a perpetual fund "for the benefit of any men or women of distinction in Canadian letters (or their dependents) ... in destitution." At his request
Lord Bessborough, the Governor-General of Canada, was the first patron of the society. However, during the
Great Depression it had difficulty obtaining funds. The first beneficiary of the Writers Foundation was Sir
Charles G.D. Roberts, who had followed the custom of the time in selling his books outright to publishers. In his old age he was poverty-stricken. The Foundation obtained a government grant, but it expired when Sir Charles died. Edgar succeeded Sir
Robert Falconer as president of the foundation in 1943 and led a thrust to have it incorporated as the Canadian Writers’ Foundation in 1945. Pelham Edgar told the 1945 convention of the Canadian Authors Association of the lack of funds. A levy of 50 cents a year from the CAA members was proposed but rejected. However, contributions in excess of this amount continued to be given by CAA branches and individual members. Edgar's first wife died in 1933, and in 1935 he married Dona Gertrude Cameron Waller. They had one daughter. Pelham Edgar died in
Canton, Ontario, on 7 October 1948. He was aged 77. Northrop Frye, who became a professor of the English department, edited a collection of his essays for posthumous publication. Frye described Pelham Edgar as a "uniquely important figure in Canadian letters."
Bernard Keble Sandwell later joked that Edgar was so influential that the
P.E.N. Club of Toronto took its initials from "Pelham Edgar's Nominees."
E.K. Brown wrote, "No academic figure has done more to foster Canadian literature than Pelham Edgar. ==Works==