When
People of the Cumberland had its New York theatrical premiere in 1938, film critic Frank S. Nugent of
The New York Times dismissed it by calling it "a propaganda film–rather than a documentary...it doesn't carry much conviction as propaganda and not much weight as a film." Film historian Russell Campbell, in his book
Cinema Strikes Back: Radical Filmmaking in the United States 1930-1942, criticized the film's People's Front ideology and argued that "square dancing and hog calling, delightful as they are, are no substitute for serious political thinking." In contrast, William Alexander, in his book
Film on the Left, writes, "it is remarkably tight, engaging, and warming, and I think perhaps the best gauged of all Frontier Films to reach its audience. It remains a film of subtlety and high skill, one of the best progressive films produced in the thirties." ==References==