Once the rebels had disbanded Scrope and Mowbray were arrested by Westmoreland and taken to
Pontefract Castle to await the king who arrived with his army at York in early June.
Thomas Arundel, the
Archbishop of Canterbury, rode overnight to argue that Scrope as Archbishop of York needed to be tried by Parliament. The king instead decided on a commission headed by the
Earl of Arundel and
Sir Thomas Beaufort to sit in judgment on the archbishop, Mowbray and Plumpton in Scrope's own hall at his manor of
Bishopthorpe, some three miles south of
York. The chief justice,
Sir William Gascoigne, refused to participate in such irregular proceedings and to pronounce judgment on a Prince of the Church, and it was thus left to the lawyer Sir William Fulthorpe to condemn Scrope to death for
high treason. Scrope, Mowbray and Plumpton were taken to a field belonging to the
nunnery of Clementhorpe which lay just under the walls of
York, and before a great crowd were
beheaded on 8 June 1405. Archbishop Scrope requested the executioner to deal him five blows in remembrance of the
Five Wounds of Christ, which was a popular devotion in Catholic England. After his execution, Archbishop Richard Scrope was buried in
York Minster. Henry IV then moved his army to take the northern Percy fortresses, using cannon in England for the first time Percy together with Thomas Bardolf escaped to
Scotland and
lost his title. Henry IV was ill until the end of his reign and some medieval writers felt that he was struck with
leprosy as a punishment for his execution of an Archbishop. ==Treatment by Shakespeare==