Burns was a tall ruckman and full-back who made his debut in 1881, aged 16 years, with
Ballarat Imperials before transferring to powerful VFA club
South Melbourne in 1885.
South Melbourne (VFA) Burns played 126 games for South and played in four premierships before joining
Geelong in 1892.
Geelong (VFA and VFL) In his last VFA game, in Round 20 of 1896, Burns played his 216th career game to break the Victorian elite football games record held by former South Melbourne teammate and captain
Henry "Sonny" Elms. Following the Victorian Football League's formation in
1897, Burns would play a further 89 games before his retirement during the
1902 season, which was due to a leg injury he sustained while playing for
Victoria against
South Australia on 26 June 1902 rather than any loss of form. Burns served as Geelong's timekeeper from his retirement in 1902 until the end of the
1941 VFL season (the sixtieth year of his association with Australian rules football). Geelong did not compete in the VFL competition in 1942 and 1943, due to war-time travel restrictions.
1899 team of "champions" At the end of the 1899 season, in the process of naming his own "champion player", the football correspondent for
The Argus,
Reginald Wilmot ("Old Boy"), selected a team of the best players of the 1899 VFL competition: • Backs:
Maurie Collins (Essendon),
Bill Proudfoot (Collingwood),
Peter Burns (Geelong). • Halfbacks:
Pat Hickey (Fitzroy),
George Davidson (South Melbourne),
Alf Wood (Melbourne). • Centres:
Fred Leach (Collingwood),
Firth McCallum (Geelong),
Harry Wright (Essendon). • Wings:
Charlie Pannam (Collingwood),
Eddie Drohan (Fitzroy),
Herb Howson (South Melbourne). • Forwards:
Bill Jackson (Essendon),
Eddy James (Geelong),
Charlie Colgan (South Melbourne). • Ruck:
Mick Pleass (South Melbourne),
Frank Hailwood (Collingwood),
Joe McShane (Geelong). • Rovers:
Dick Condon (Collingwood),
Bill McSpeerin (Fitzroy),
Teddy Rankin (Geelong). From those he considered to be the three best players — that is, Condon, Hickey, and Pleass — Wilmot selected Pat Hickey as his "champion player" of the season. ==305 VFA/VFL games==