Alcohol abuse and Native Americans in Pennsylvania Beginning around 1675, traders had been selling rum in Shawnee communities. Several violent deaths were attributed to its influence. In October 1701 the
Pennsylvania Assembly had prohibited the sale of rum to Native American people. Because the law was poorly enforced in the frontier society, and the penalty was light—a fine of ten
pounds and confiscation of any illegal supplies—traders continued to use rum to
barter for furs. Traders soon began selling rum on
credit in order to
extort furs and skins and labor from the Shawnee. Native American leaders objected to the widespread use of alcohol. The minutes of the
Provincial Council of Pennsylvania for 16 May 1704 record a complaint submitted by Chief Ortiagh of the
Conestoga Indians:
Attempts to control the sale of alcohol On 24 April 1733 the Shawnee chiefs at
"Allegania" sent a petition to Governor Gordon complaining that "There is yearly and monthly some new upstart of a trader without license, who comes amongst us and brings with him nothing but rum ..." and asking permission to destroy the casks of rum: "We therefore beg thou would take it into consideration, and send us two firm orders, one for Peter Chartier, the other for us, to break in pieces all the [casks] so brought." On 1 May 1734 several Shawnee chiefs dictated a letter to a trader, probably Jonah Davenport: it listed the names of fifteen traders who either had no license or had shown undesirable behavior, such as frequent disputes or violence. Chartier was among seven who were listed as in
good standing. The chiefs would allow those men to bring up to 60 gallons of rum a year to their communities, as long as they had a valid license. Chartier was described as "one of us, and he is welcome to come as long as he pleases ... [and] to bring what quantity [of rum] he pleases ..." The letter concludes, "And for our parts, if we see any other traders than those we desire amongst us, we will stave their [casks] and seize their goods." He decided to prohibit the sale of rum in Shawnee communities in his area, and persuaded other chiefs to do the same. In a letter of 20 March 1738, addressed to
Thomas Penn and Acting Governor
James Logan, three Shawnee chiefs stated: Chartier and ninety-eight Shawnee signed a pledge that accompanied the letter: it agreed that all rum should be spilled, and four men should be appointed for every town to prevent rum or strong liquor being brought into their towns for four years. Traders continued to take rum into Shawnee communities, including several traders whom the Shawnees had specifically requested be barred from their territory. For several years the French government had been trying to win the support of indigenous communities as part of their competition with the British in North America. In 1740 the
Governor of New France,
Charles de la Boische, Marquis de Beauharnois, invited Chartier and other Shawnee leaders to meet in
Montreal to discuss relocating to Detroit (then under French control) and forming an alliance. In a letter of 25 June 1740 Chartier declined, promising to visit Montreal the following year (a promise which he apparently did not keep). Several Shawnee communities from the
Chalahgawtha,
Pekowi and
Mekoche bands later resettled near Chartier's Town.
Chartier's flight from Pennsylvania, 1745 Frustrated in his efforts to control the rum trade, Chartier decided to lead his band away from the area. With some 400 Pekowi Shawnee, he left their settlement and headed southwest. In July 1745 traders James Dunning (who had been banned by the Shawnee in 1734) and Peter Tostee appeared in Philadelphia. They claimed to authorities that they had been robbed on the frontier on 18 April: George Croghan, another trader, later testified that Chartier had set free a Black servant, possibly a slave, who was traveling with Dunning and Tostee. The Pennsylvania provincial council issued an indictment against "Peter Chartier of Lancaster County ... Labourer [who], being moved and seduced by the instigation of the Devil ... falsely, traitorously, unlawfully and treasonably did
compass, imagine and intend open war, insurrection and rebellion against our said
Lord the King." Chartier's landholdings in Pennsylvania, totaling some 600 acres, were seized and turned over to Thomas Lawrence, a business partner of
Edward Shippen, III. Chartier and his people recognized that, by defying the Provincial Governor and accepting French
patronage, they had to leave Pennsylvania, which was under British control. In June an anonymous Frenchman visited Lower Shawneetown, sent by
Paul-Joseph Le Moyne de Longueuil, commandant at Detroit, to take charge of captives Chartier was presumed to have taken when he robbed traders Dunning and Tostee. Chartier had released the traders after robbing them, however. The Frenchman observed Chartier trying unsuccessfully to persuade the leaders of Lower Shawneetown to accept French alliance: This Frenchman watched the Shawnee who had accompanied Chartier performing a two-day "Death Feast," a ceremony conducted before abandoning a village. while others believe that this is probably inaccurate, and that Chartier never actually lived there, although "a band of Shawnee may have established the village in 1750 or 1751 and it may have been abandoned in 1754 due to attacks by the Catawbas." According to Charles Augustus Hanna (1911): Fighting with
Iroquois and
Chickasaw and an outbreak of smallpox led them to move south to the
Coosa River in 1748, where they founded the village of Chalakagay, near what is now
Sylacauga, Alabama.
Black Hoof (1740–1831), then a child, was with this band and recalled the journey in later years when he was a chief. The Pennsylvania government continued to offer a
bounty for Chartier as late as 1747, when
James Adair tried to catch him in South Carolina. Adair later wrote: ==Visit to Detroit, 1747==