Headlander received "generally favorable" reviews for PlayStation 4 and "mixed or average" reviews for PC according to aggregate review website
Metacritic.
IGN gave the game an 8.2 out of 10, writing, "
Headlander is an unexpectedly great take on Metroidviania-style action. Some of the objective design renders its flashier, body-endangering powers moot, but the quick and complex moment-to-moment gameplay carries it splendidly. It's difficult but fair, and fast-paced but satisfying through to the end."
PC Gamer called
Headlander's tone "inconsistent" and noted that the title played things safe, sticking to tropes in its genre, but heavily praised its aesthetics, writing, "its gorgeously kitschy world of thrumming synths and dazzling colour makes for an unforgettable adventure".
Destructoid reviewed the game negatively, lamenting the lack of depth in the aesthetics, combat, exploration, themes, and plot, writing, "
Headlander knows what it is but doesn't know what it wants to be."
Game Informer wrote, "
Headlander doesn't forge a bold new path, but it's a lot of fun to live in its strange world for a while. Its various elements are well trod – '70s aesthetic, Metroid-style exploration, big questions about the nature of identity and consciousness – but they've been arranged in a fascinating way that feels fresh."
GameSpot similarly appreciated the game's visuals, aesthetics, characters, score, and movement while criticizing the repetitive dialogue, minor technical issues, bosses, and combat.
GamesRadar+ praised the title's take on the Metroidvania formula and its pacing while taking issue with the backtracking and finicky combat.
Push Square called the game "one of the best games that Double Fine has ever produced", writing, "Everything about it is so finely tuned, from its gunplay to its platforming to its puzzles, and it doesn't just stay true to classic Metroidvanias – it also builds upon the foundations that they laid. The story is well told, the characters are entertaining, the environments are fleshed out, and the humour is as brilliant as always." ==References==