Diplomat and apologist Around 1173, Peter went to England to take up a post as chief letter-writer for
Richard of Dover, Becket's successor as
Archbishop. He also entered the service of
Henry II, acting as a diplomat in his negotiations with
Louis VII of France and the
Papacy. His arrival in England approximately coincided with the rupture of the ruling family and the eruption of civil strife all over the
Angevin Empire, carefully fomented by the French monarchy. Peter wrote an open letter to the queen,
Eleanor of Aquitaine, to "deplore publicly and regretfully that, while you are a most prudent woman, you have left your husband." However, when in 1183
Henry the Young King died during the revolt against his father, Peter wrote to Eleanor a letter of reasoned consolation. Peter was a well-connected controversialist and propagandist for Henry II. He wrote in praise of him to continental contacts, like
Walter Ophamil, now Archbishop of Palermo, defending him against the charge that he had deliberately instigated the murder of Thomas Becket. In introducing the subject of Becket's death, Peter mentioned in passing his own
clerical order:
in verbo Domini et in ordine diaconi vobis dico – “in the Word of God and the order of deacon I speak to you.” At some stage in his education, he had been
ordained a
deacon and he seems to have avoided ordination to the
priesthood. In 1176 Peter was appointed
Chancellor of the
Archdiocese of Canterbury, the chief record keeper and
Latin secretary, serving Richard of Dover. Probably in the same year, he was appointed
Archdeacon of Bath, Peter was in Rome in 1179 and there displayed the improvidence which was to become an important feature of his later life. His failure to repay a debt caused
Pope Alexander III to write to the Archbishop on behalf of the creditor. This was a
cause célèbre sufficient for inclusion in a compendium of
canon law issued in 1234 by
Pope Gregory IX. Richard of Dover died in 1184 and, after some delay, the king succeeded in getting Baldwin of Forde, Peter's friend and tutor from his Bologna days, installed as Archbishop of Canterbury. He confirmed Peter in his position as letter writer but also made him his chief legal adviser.
The Canterbury Cathedral chapter controversy Baldwin soon created a legal storm that was to engulf Peter, threatening his career. He was determined to reform the diocese thoroughly, making it function more efficiently as a base for his position as one of the chief magnates of the realm. He saw the
chapter of
Canterbury Cathedral as a major obstacle. Like most cathedral establishments, it had consisted of
secular clergy until the
Norman Conquest, after which it was reconstituted as a community of
Benedictine monks, known variously as the Priory of the Holy Trinity or Christchurch. However, the monks of the chapter were soon complaining to his successor, Urban III, that his reforms were going too far and succeeded in getting the Pope to order restoration of some of the confiscated churches. Urban initially welcomed some aspects of Baldwin's overarching plan to move the chapter to
Hackington, north of Canterbury, and to build a second base for the diocese at
Lambeth, directly facing the centres of secular power in London and Westminster. However, the plan unfolded to include the replacement of the monastic chapter with a new episcopal staff, consisting of
colleges of secular clergy at Hackington and Lambeth. Seeing their influence and wealth slipping from their grasp, the Canterbury monks appealed to both the king and to Rome. Baldwin suspended the
prior in December 1186 and the monks immediately began a letter-writing campaign to mobilise bishops, archbishops, even
Philip II of France, in their cause. Peter of Blois was despatched to the papal court at
Verona to counter the chapter's arguments, which were presented by a skilled Roman lawyer called Pillius. Peter arrived at Verona a few days later to find the Pope had adjourned the case until 10 April, giving Peter no chance to plead formally while a further series of decrees was issued in the monks' favour. However, Peter was no more successful in open court, suffering a continuing series of defeats. On 9 May the Pope ordered Archbishop Baldwin to cease building his new church at Hackington, abolished the fraternity he had established to staff and support it, and expressed surprise that he had so far resisted restoration of the situation to that prevailing before the appeal. Peter remained at Verona, arguing the case, until October, and then followed the papal court to
Ferrara. Provocative behaviour back home did not help Peter. Baldwin continued to build his church in defiance of the Pope but with the king's support, although he did move the site some distance to the west, hurriedly putting up a wooden chapel in St Dunstan's parish. In August he seized the chapter's
manors, suspending and even
excommunicating its members as he saw fit. On 3 October, having reached Ferrara, the Pope raised the stakes by ordering Baldwin actually to demolish his new headquarters, to desecrate the site and to suspend its clergy, to restore all members of the existing chapter to office and to refrain from further actions against them while the case continued. He was given 30 days to comply.
R. W. Southern alleges that Peter made a last, personal appeal to his old teacher while riding from Verona to Ferrara, and that the Pope was so incensed by the attempt to circumvent legal procedure that he died the following day of a heart attack. Peter's own later account of Urban's death has him taken ill while changing horses, shortly after Peter had approached him, but also mentions he contracted
dysentery on the journey from Verona – an entirely plausible cause of death. The new pope moved the court to
Pisa on its way towards Rome. He seems to have been less sympathetic to the Cathedral chapter while Honorius, like Peter, remained at the papal court, as he had been ordered to return there by the chapter. However, on 26 January 1188, Clement made a final decision on the matter, which he communicated in a letter to Baldwin. He rebuked the archbishop for his lack of moderation, which tended to undermine the dignity of his office, and for his disobedience, before repeating all of Urban's demands: the new
collegiate church was forbidden and the previous situation was to be restored. Baldwin continued his vindictive campaign against the monks, who were imprisoned in their own priory at the cathedral until August 1189, ==Later years==