According to the hypothesized
Titius–Bode law proposed in the 1700s to explain the spacing of planets in a solar system, a planet may have once existed between Mars and Jupiter. After learning of the regular sequence discovered by the German astronomer and mathematician
Johann Daniel Titius, astronomer
Johann E. Bode urged a search for the fifth planet corresponding to a gap in the sequence.
(1) Ceres, the largest
asteroid in the asteroid belt (now considered a
dwarf planet), was serendipitously discovered in 1801 by the Italian
Giuseppe Piazzi and found to closely match the "empty" position in
Titius' sequence, which led many to believe it to be the "missing planet". However, in 1802
astronomer Heinrich Wilhelm Matthäus Olbers discovered and named the asteroid
(2) Pallas, a second object in roughly the same orbit as (1) Ceres. Olbers proposed that these two discoveries were the fragments of a
disrupted planet that had formerly orbited the Sun, and predicted that more of these pieces would be found. The discovery of the asteroid
(3) Juno by
Karl Ludwig Harding and
(4) Vesta by Olbers, buttressed his hypothesis. In 1823, German linguist and retired teacher called Olbers' destroyed planet
Phaëthon, linking it to the
Greek myths and legends about
Phaethon and others. In 1927,
Franz Xaver Kugler wrote a short book titled
Sibyllinischer Sternkampf und Phaëthon in naturgeschichtlicher Beleuchtung (The Sybilline Battle of the Stars and Phaeton Seen as Natural History). The central idea in Kugler's book is that the myth of Phaethon was based on a real event: Making use of ancient sources, Kugler argued that Phaeton had been a very bright celestial object that appeared around 1500 BC which fell to
Earth not long afterwards as a shower of large meteorites, causing catastrophic fires and floods in Africa and elsewhere. Hypotheses regarding the formation of the asteroid belt from the destruction of a hypothetical
fifth planet are today collectively referred to as "
the disruption theory". These hypotheses state that there was once a major planetary member of the
Solar System circulating in the present gap between Mars and Jupiter, which was destroyed by one or more of the following hypothetical processes: • it veered too close to Jupiter and was torn apart by its powerful tides • it was struck by another large celestial body • it was destroyed by a hypothetical
brown dwarf, the companion star to the
Sun, known as
Nemesis • it was shattered by some internal catastrophe In 1953, Soviet Russian astronomer
Ivan I. Putilin suggested that Phaeton was destroyed due to
centrifugal forces, giving it a diameter of approximately (slightly larger than Mars' diameter of ) and a rotational speed of 2.6 hours. Eventually, the planet became so distorted that parts of it near its equator were spun off into space.
Outgassing of gases once stored in Phaeton's interior caused multiple explosions, sending material into space and forming
asteroid families. However, his hypothesis was not widely accepted. Two years later in 1955,
Odesan astronomer
Konstantin N. Savchenko suggested that Ceres, Pallas, Juno, and Vesta were not fragments of Phaeton, but rather its former moons. Phaeton had an additional fifth satellite, assumed to be the size of Ceres, orbiting near the planet's
Hill sphere, and thus more subject to gravitational perturbations from Jupiter. As a result, the fifth satellite became tidally detached and orbited the Sun for millions of years afterward, making periodic close misses with Phaeton that slowly increased its velocity. Once the escaped satellite re-entered Phaeton's Hill sphere, it collided with the planet at high speed, shattering it while Ceres, Pallas, Juno, and Vesta assumed heliocentric orbits. Simulations showed that for such a Ceres-sized body to shatter Phaeton, it would need to be travelling at nearly . The disrupted planet hypothesis was also supported by French–Italian mathematician and astronomer
Joseph-Louis Lagrange in 1814; Canadian geologist
Reginald Daly in 1943; American geochemists
Harrison Brown and
Clair Patterson in 1948; Soviet academics
Alexander Zavaritskiy in 1948,
Vasily Fesenkov in 1950 (who later rejected his own model) and
Otto Schmidt (died 1956); and American astronomer
Donald Menzel (1901–1976) in 1978. Ovenden suggested that the planet be named "
Krypton" after the destroyed native world of
Superman, as well as believing it to have been a
gas giant roughly eighty-five to ninety
Earth masses in mass and nearly the size of
Saturn. Most astronomers today believe that the asteroids in the main belt are remnants of the
protoplanetary disk that never formed a planet and that in this region the amalgamation of protoplanets into a planet was prevented by the disruptive gravitational perturbations of Jupiter during the formative period of the
Solar System. ==Other hypotheses ==