In 1964, Alderisio and
Irwin Weiner were tried but later acquitted for extorting a Miami businessman. Weiner and Alderisio were particularly close as Weiner had known him since he was 13. Weiner owned a bail bonds company and would post bail for Alderisio's underlings. In 1967 they became partners in the International Fiberglass Company. In 1965, Alderisio was convicted, along with his long-time acquaintances Willie Alderman and Ruby Kolod, of conspiring to transmit communications containing threats to kidnap or injure persons in interstate commerce, stemming from an extortion scheme targeting Denver lawyer Robert Sunshine. Alderisio, who had been described by Kolod as "a Chicago lawyer" who would not be coming for the purpose of suing Sunshine, told Sunshine "Ruby sent us. We came here to kill you." The case marked an early federal push against organized crime figures using interstate threat statutes, before the enactment of the
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, with evidence drawn from the
FBI's electronic surveillance of Kolod's offices in the
Desert Inn in
Las Vegas and Alderisio's place of business in Chicago. Alderisio appealed his conviction on a number of grounds, including his claim that the evidence on which the government relied was tainted by the FBI's admittedly unlawful wiretaps. His case reached the
United States Supreme Court, which ruled that Alderisio did not have standing to challenge the evidence derived from the surveillance of Kolos's offices based on the violation of Kolod's
Fourth Amendment rights, but that he was entitled to limited access to the records of the unlawful surveillance of his business premises following
in camera review of surveillance logs by the trial court. On remand the Tenth Circuit upheld the convictions. Following exhaustion of his appeals, the Court ordered Alderisio to four and one-half years' imprisonment plus a $7,500 fine. Alderisio's imprisonment led to
Joey Aiuppa's replacement of him as front boss. ==Personal life and death==