After Klay left active military service, he enrolled in Hunter College’s Creative Writing program, which was then under the directorship of his former professor, poet
Tom Sleigh, whom Klay knew from the English department at Dartmouth. While completing his MFA at Hunter, Klay established important and vital artistic relationships with not only Sleigh, but also
Peter Carey,
Colum McCann,
Claire Messud,
Patrick McGrath, and
Nathan Englander. He has also reviewed fiction for
The New York Times,
The Washington Post, and
Newsweek. His stories have appeared in collections as well, including
The Best American Non-Required Reading 2012 (Mariner Books) and
Fire and Forget (Da Capo Press, 2013). He has conducted several interviews with other writers and published them on
The Rumpus.
Princeton University named him a Hodder Fellow for the 2015-2016 academic year. In 2018, he headed the five-member jury that awarded the first
Aspen Words Literary Prize. In July 2018, Klay was named 2018 winner of the George W. Hunt, S.J., Prize for Journalism, Arts & Letters in the category Cultural & Historical Criticism. Klay’s first novel, entitled
Missionaries, was published by
Penguin Press in October 2020. It was included on Barack Obama’s perennial list of his favorite books of the year. , Klay was a faculty member in the Masters of Fine Arts (MFA) creative writing program at
Fairfield University. In 2022, Klay returned a second time on the
Storybound podcast for a special adaptation of his essay "Citizen Soldier". Klay wrote a New York Times
op-ed entilted "Trump Has Made a Fundamental Miscalculation about Iran" on March 22, 2026. It was published on the website and the New York edition of the print paper. ==Reception and recognition==