On 15 March 2019 there was a
mass shooting in Christchurch targeting
Muslims. The terrorist carried a camera throughout, livestreaming to social media. The resulting video of the shooting was quickly classified by
David Shanks of the
Office of Film and Literature Classification as "objectionable" under the
Films, Videos, and Publications Classification Act 1993, making it a criminal offense to possess or distribute it, and police took action against 13 people in relation to the video. and asked a friend to modify it by adding cross-hairs and a "kill count". When arrested he told police that he "could not give a fuck, mate" about the shooting victims. At one of his court appearances, Arps distributed copies of the "Holocaust Handbooks" series by German
holocaust denier Germar Rudolf to journalists and the public. In June 2019, Arps was sentenced to 21 months in jail, with
Massey University distinguished professor
Paul Spoonley describing him as "an unrepentant, hardcore white supremacist". At his sentencing Judge Stephen O'Driscoll described Arps as "remorseless". His pre-sentencing report included matters that gave the judge "real concern", including Arps comparing himself to
Rudolf Hess, Deputy Führer of Nazi Germany. Arps filed the first of two unsuccessful appeals against his sentence on the day he received it. While in prison, Arps sent letters to
Newshub which praised mass murderer
Anders Breivik, threatened harm to Prime Minister
Jacinda Ardern, and expressed a desire to see a former Prime Minister publicly executed. Newshub did not publish the letter. The Government announced plans to change the way letters written by extremist prisoners are vetted before sending. His sentencing and unsuccessful appeals were later referenced by the
Royal Commission of Inquiry into the terrorist attack as part of its paper on hate crime. Answering a question from the public the Commission of Inquiry also reported "no evidence [the shooter] knows Philip Arps or that there was any other connection between them."
Complaint about being called a "white supremacist" Arps was called a "
white supremacist" in a television piece filmed by
Newshub journalist
Patrick Gower and broadcast on 30 June 2019. He submitted a complaint to the
Broadcasting Standards Authority (BSA) on the grounds that this label was "inaccurate and unbalanced". The BSA found that "we do not consider the issue of whether Mr Arps is a ‘white supremacist’ to be a controversial issue" and that Gower's words were "clearly a statement of analysis and opinion". Arps's complaint was not upheld. Media reports have regularly described Arps as a white supremacist since the ruling.
Newshubs reports on a court appearance in December 2020, a 2022
New Zealand Herald column by sociologist Jarrod Gilbert, and
Stuffs reporting into Arps's run for a high school board of trustees all used the term directly or indirectly. Other sources have called him a 'neo-Nazi', including a 2023 book review by a University of Auckland academic and a 2019
Newsroom article.
Parole breaches Arps was released from prison in January 2020, his release being automatic, having served half of a sentence of less than two years. Release conditions were imposed, including wearing a GPS monitor, making no contact with members of the Muslim community, and not owning or using firearms. He unsuccessfully appealed against these conditions with a judge noting Arps's "deep-seated enmity towards people of the Muslim and Jewish faiths" as a reason to retain them. Corrections were made to pay $3,000 towards Arps's costs. In December he returned to court and a new condition was added, preventing him from coming within 100m of the Linwood Islamic Centre. New charges related to breach of his electronic monitoring conditions were filed against Arps on 8 January 2021, and he was given a March 2021 court date. ==Further offending and trials==