In October 2007,
Maricopa County sheriff's deputies arrested Lacey and Larkin on charges of revealing secret
grand jury information concerning the investigations of the
New Timess long-running feud with Maricopa County
sheriff Joe Arpaio. In July 2004, the
New Times published Arpaio's home address in the context of a story about his real estate dealings, which the County Attorney's office was investigating as a possible crime under Arizona state law. Special prosecutor Dennis Wilenchik served Village Voice Media with a subpoena ordering it to produce "all documents" related to the original real estate article, as well as "all Internet web site traffic information" to a number of articles that mentioned Arpaio. Wilenchik further ordered Village Voice Media to produce the
IP addresses of all visitors to the
Phoenix New Times website since January 1, 2004, as well as which websites those readers had been to prior to visiting. As an act of "
civil disobedience", Lacey and Larkin published the contents of the subpoena on or about October 18, which resulted in their arrests the same day. On the following day, the county attorney dropped the case after declining to pursue charges against the two. Special prosecutor Dennis Wilenchik's subpoena included a demand for the names of all people who had read the Arpaio story on the newspaper's website. It was the revealing of the subpoena information by the
New Times which led to the arrests.
Maricopa County Attorney
Andrew Thomas dropped the charges less than 24 hours after the two were arrested. In the weeks following the arrests, members of the
Association of Alternative Newsweeklies, of which the
Phoenix New Times is a member, provided links on their websites to places where Arpaio's address could be found. This was done to show solidarity with the
Phoenix New Times. In February 2008, the paper filed a formal notice of claim, which is required by Arizona law before suing government officials. In December 2013, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors agreed to pay
Phoenix New Times founders Michael Lacey and Jim Larkin $3.75 million to settle their false arrest lawsuit against the county defendants. == Restraining order controversy ==