Pierrot's expression is the most highly debated part of the work. Some scholars read it as stupidity, while others see melancholy, poignancy, or even revery. The association of the painting with melancholy has often led scholars to see the painting as a depiction of a "sad clown." Art historian
Donald Posner refutes these claims, arguing that Pierrot's theatrical persona was not understood as a sad, lonely clown until the 19th century. Further, he argues that in Watteau's time Pierrot was more simple-minded and not inclined to display sensitive emotions, making Pierrot an improbable subject for melancholic self-reflection. The background actors serve a vital role by using their varied, almost rhythmic poses to accentuate Pierrot’s rigidity, as if he were frozen in time. Separated from Pierrot below the mound, the actor's calm engagement with one another while ignoring Pierrot's presence serves to isolate Pierrot not only spatially, but also emotionally, highlighting his detachment from the group of fellow actors. Pierrot’s identity is defined by the awkward proportions of his costume. The immense volume of his jacket and its oversized sleeves seem to weigh him down, while his short pants further highlight his foolish nature. This foolishness is again magnified by his fellow actors. The man in red wears a bright, well-fitting suit that stands in sharp contrast to Pierrot's, signaling the clown's incompetence compared to the rest of the actors. == Provenance and legacy ==