Whitaker (1801) says that the existence of the Pilgrims' Cross, as mentioned in 1225, indicated the route of pilgrims travelling from the north of England to
Walsingham and
Canterbury. Land in
Holcombe Forest was left in that year to
Bretton Priory, including "three acres of meadow near Pilgrims' Cross Shaw ... a resting place of the pilgrims". He also mentions the
Plantaganets and
Lacys, who travelled via the monument's location to
Lancaster, from their castles in
Clitheroe and
Pontefract. "What trains of
sumpter horses must upon these occasions have been seen traversing these boggy wastes, impassable at that time for carriages. This was the line the Lacys were condemned to pursue". A letter from the Reverend Henry Dowsett to the
Manchester Evening News was published on 24 August of the same year: The Rector of Holcombe ... writes that the massive foundation, all that remained of the ancient Pilgrims' cross stone on Holcombe Hill, has recently been destroyed. The stone was seen alright three weeks ago, but now it has been broken up.. The cross was close to the ancient moorland footpath, and is mentioned as far back as 1225. It was probably in position on Holcombe Hill at a much earlier date. The stone was a block of
sandstone, weighing perhaps a ton, and showing the cavity squared for the shaft almost as well cut as when it left the
mason's hands 700 years ago. There was only just a little weathering of the angles. A simple block of sandstone ... now it lies in fragments ... scattered here and there ... The stone was not a quarried one. It belonged to that class found upon our hillsides here, among
glacial drift and
moraine matter. It was of rather a finer grain than the stone now being quarried on our moor ... Our Pilgrims' Cross stone had been
dressed and squared by the mason's hand, though a little roughly so here and there. By 1903 the identity of the vandals was still unknown. The
Manchester City News said: Its demolition is an act of pure vandalism, for which one can find no excuse, and for which it is difficult even to suggest a motive. It appears to have been carried out by clumsy depredators. Wedges had been inserted in the block.The wedge holes were badly made, and other marks show the unskilful use of heavy hammers. The destruction was evidently committed on the site, and the broken fragments were afterwards carried to the wet boghole, twenty yards distant, in which they were found. Unfortunately they are too numerous, there being at least fifty, for any hope to be entertained of the stone being pieced together again and replaced in its old site. The cart was pulled from Fletcher Bank Quarry at the other side of the Irwell Valley, "with much laborious effort". The monument is constructed of two
Millstone Grit blocks, weighing in total roughly . and headed the fundraising committee. On 28 June 1902, The stone was funded by subscription. The inscription states that "Pilgrims to Whalley Abbey prayed and rested here", but
Whalley Abbey was not founded until the late 13th century when the monks relocated from nearby
Stanlow Abbey in April 1296. In fact, Rev. Henry Dowsett, who ordered the inscription on the stone, confirmed the cross pre-dated the abbey, minutes after
dedicating the memorial monument in 1902. He said that: ==Later history==