Viewers In its original American broadcast, "Pilot" was seen by an estimated 4.56 million household viewers with a 2.2/5 in the 18–49 demographics. This means that 2.2 percent of all households with televisions watched the episode, while 5 percent of all of those watching television at the time of the broadcast watched it.
Critical reviews "Pilot" received a positive response from critics. Michael Peck of
TV Guide wrote, "I've come to realize that as much as I worry that I watch too much TV to feel adequately optimistic about the medium, I still turn on a new HBO show hoping they've scored another
Sopranos or
Deadwood and not just an
Arliss. Never mind that I want to see Bill Paxton in something good. I have a soft spot for the guy, since pretty much every male of a certain age can, like myself, recite line after line of him as Chet in
Weird Science, and as "Game over!" space Marine Hudson in
Aliens. And that's not even mentioning other great stuff like
One False Move and
A Simple Plan. The short version: I'm primed to like this." Michael Sciannamea of
TV Squad wrote, "I wasn't quite sure what to make of
Big Love. The acting was good and the dialogue was snappy and to the point. However, I felt incredibly weird after watching it, sort of the same way I felt after watching
The Book of Daniel when it was on NBC. Are the writers and producers trying to shock the audience first and somehow develop a story around it?"
Television Without Pity gave the episode a "B+" grade.
Maureen Ryan of
Chicago Tribune wrote, "Did someone mention
Lost? Well, it's a stretch, but one can find parallels between
Big Love and that ABC series. You could argue that both serialized, slow-building dramas are about how one defines, and constructs, a family. There are fewer adventures on
Big Love, but almost as many confused folks in search of salvation." Lynn Neary of
NPR wrote, "Mark Olsen and Will Scheffer, the show's co-creators, say they are not trying to push an agenda with Big Love. They just think of it as a show about what it means to be a family."
Accolades For the episode, García received a nomination for
Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series at the
58th Primetime Emmy Awards. He would lose to
Jon Cassar, who won for directing the episode "
Day 5: 7:00 a.m. – 8:00 a.m." for
24. == References ==