Neurobiologist
Dick Swaab acknowledged van Lommel’s work for documenting patients’ reported experiences and bringing the topic of near-death experiences to wider medical attention, while criticizing
Consciousness Beyond Life for what he described as a lack of engagement with established neurobiological explanations and for borrowing concepts from
quantum mechanics without sufficient scientific basis. Cognitive neuroscientist Jason Braithwaite published a detailed critique of van Lommel’s 2001
Lancet study, arguing that although it contributed useful observational data, it contained factual and logical errors, including misinterpretations of anoxia and overreliance on EEG findings as indicators of total brain inactivity. Skeptical commentators have also questioned claims related to alleged
psychic abilities reported by some individuals with near-death experiences, arguing that such interpretations rely on self-reported data and lack independent verification. == Publications ==