'' and established
Yeah Yeah Yeahs as prominent figures in the 2000s
garage rock and
post-punk revival. Pictured from left to right are Brian Chase, Karen O and Nick Zinner in 2002. "Maps" became Yeah Yeah Yeahs's
signature song and cemented their status in the 2000s
garage rock and
post-punk revivals. Emma Madden of
Billboard believed the song and its music video "helped change the way we view the relationship between
pop and indie", writing that "Those real tears, sweaty hair and desperate insistence of "Wait! They don't love you like I love you" became a source of true human emotion that pop records have been co-opting since its release in 2003." Reflecting on the song's impact, Karen O said, "It's a love song, and there’s just not a lot of bands that have one of their biggest songs as a love song. So I'm pretty stoked about that".
NME deemed "Maps" the best alternative love song of all time in 2011; the same publication ranked it at number 55 on its list of "150 Best Tracks of the Past 15 Years" that same year.
Rolling Stone ranked it at number seven on their "100 Best Songs of the 2000s" list and number 386 on their "
500 Greatest Songs of All Time" list, both in 2011; the 2021 revision of the latter moved it to number 101.
Rolling Stone also ranked it second on their list of "The 250 Greatest Songs of the 21st Century So Far" in 2025. In September 2024, a sped-up version of "Maps" gained popularity on
TikTok. A dance was created along with it where it used different contexts of wanting someone to stop and listen to them. As a result, the song charted at number one on the US
TikTok Billboard Top 50 the following month. == Other versions ==