Pinball Dreams was a commercial success, selling more than 650,000 copies in its debut year.
Pinball Dreams was overall received positive by press reviews.
Electronic Gaming Monthly gave the Game Gear version a 5.8 out of 10, commenting that "Pinball never really worked well on portable systems and
Pinball Dreams is no exception. The boards are huge, but the game is a little slow." Power Unlimited gave the Game Boy version a score of 85% summarizing: "Sharp graphics, excellent sound and simple controls all contribute to a game that will hardly get boring. And with the three different cabinets there is also variety. In 1993
Computer Gaming World criticized the PC version of
Pinball Dreams as having "the worst physical model" of four reviewed games, and disliked the "jerk[y]" scrolling. The magazine said in June 1994 that
Pinball 2000 "is an average title at a better than average price". In 1996 the magazine ranked
Pinball Dreams as the 119th best game of all time, stating, "Smooth scrolling and great ball physics made this Amiga game a wizard's choice." In 2011,
Wirtualna Polska ranked it as the fourth best Amiga game. ==Legacy==