On September 30, 2009, a "Yankee Bowl" was announced at a
Yankee Stadium press conference by then-representatives of the involved parties: Yankees' minority owner
Hal Steinbrenner,
Mayor of New York City Michael Bloomberg,
Big East Conference commissioner
John Marinatto, and
Big 12 Conference commissioner
Dan Beebe. The most recent bowl in New York City proper had been the
1962 Gotham Bowl, which pitted
Miami (FL) against
Nebraska at the
original Yankee Stadium. The newly announced bowl planned to pair the fourth-place team from the Big East Conference against the seventh-place team from the Big 12. In the event the Big 12 lacked an eligible team,
independent Notre Dame could receive an invitation. The decision to stage a bowl game in New York City with a Big East team followed a 2004 announcement by the New York City Sports Commission and Big East Conference to hold the "Big Apple Bowl" at the proposed
West Side Stadium, but the plan to build the stadium on the West Side of
Manhattan was defeated in 2005. On March 9, 2010, the bowl's official name was announced to be the Pinstripe Bowl, with
New Era Cap Company agreeing to sponsor the bowl for four years while
ESPN agreed to broadcast the bowl for six years. The inaugural game was played on December 30, 2010. The first three editions of the bowl were each won by a Big East team over a Big 12 team. In 2013, Notre Dame was invited in place of a Big 12 team; the Fighting Irish defeated
Rutgers of the Big East's successor, the
American Athletic Conference ("The American"). Starting in 2014, the bowl featured an
Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) team against a
Big Ten team. This was the same year that New Jersey–based Rutgers, the closest FBS school in the New York City area, moved to the Big Ten, and one year after
Syracuse University, based in central
New York state, moved to the ACC. The ACC agreed to a six-year deal with the Pinstripe Bowl, and the Big Ten agreed to the alignment for eight years. The ACC adopted a tiered system so that the same conference position would not necessarily go to the same bowl each season. The 2014 through 2019 editions of the bowl saw Big Ten teams compile a 5–1 record against ACC teams. The 2020 edition of the bowl was cancelled, "out of an abundance of caution" due to the
COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. On August 16, 2022,
Bad Boy Mowers was announced as the new title sponsor of the game. ==Game results==