When Pluto's significance was changed to
dwarf planet, mnemonics could no longer include the final "P". The first notable suggestion came from Kyle Sullivan of
Lumberton, Mississippi, USA, whose mnemonic was published in the Jan. 2007 issue of
Astronomy magazine: "My Violent Evil Monster Just Scared Us Nuts". In August 2006, for the eight planets recognized under the new definition, Phyllis Lugger, professor of astronomy at Indiana University suggested the following modification to the common mnemonic for the nine planets: "My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nachos". She proposed this mnemonic to
Owen Gingerich, Chair of the
International Astronomical Union (IAU) Planet Definition Committee and published the mnemonic in the
American Astronomical Society Committee on the Status of Women in Astronomy Bulletin Board on August 25, 2006. It also appeared in Indiana University's IU News Room Star Trak on August 30, 2006. This mnemonic is used by the IAU on their website for the public. Others angry at the IAU's decision to "demote" Pluto composed sarcastic mnemonics in protest: • "Many Very Educated Men Justify Stealing Unique Ninth" – found in
Schott's Miscellany by
Ben Schott. • "Many Very Educated Men Just Screwed Up Nature" – this mnemonic is mentioned by
Mike Brown, who discovered
Eris. • "Most Very Elderly Men Just Slept Under Newspapers". Slightly risque versions include, • "Mary's 'Virgin' Explanation Made Joseph Suspect Upstairs Neighbor". ==Eleven planets and dwarf planets==