Upon release,
Play was met with widely positive reviews from
music critics. Griselda Flores from
Billboard gave the EP a positive review, saying it "is just as profound as its predecessor [
Pausa], with Martin as vulnerable as ever in navigating love and heartbreak". She described "Otra Noche en L.A." and "A Veces Bien y a Veces Mal" as "evocative ballads", while praising them for pairing "perfectly" with the other tracks, "Amordio", "Paris in Love", and "Ácido Sabor", those which she named "pop gems".
El Nuevo Día staff described it as "a collection of enigmatic melodies and rhythms accompanied by the unmistakable voice of Ricky Martin". An author of
Los 40 wrote that
Play "would culminate" his previous EP
Pausa. Writing for
LatinPop Brasil, Priscila Bertozzi commended Martin's "versatility and identity" on the EP and its "powerful cinematic and musical concept", saying he "brings a powerful metaphor to life in his new project". Lucas Villa from
Latina labeled it "[an] irresistible EP" that "is meant to be played in the bedroom", describing "Ácido Sabor", "Paris in Love", and "Amordio" as "seriously sexy", "funky", and "frisky", respectively.
Accolades Play was nominated for
Album of the Year at the
24th Annual Latin Grammy Awards, but lost to
Karol G's
Mañana Será Bonito. It was also nominated for
Pop Album of the Year at the
35th Annual Lo Nuestro Awards. ==Track listing==