Critical response On the
review aggregation website
Rotten Tomatoes, the overall series holds a 97% rating. Meanwhile, on
Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, the overall series received a score of 83 out of 100.
Season 1 garnered acclaim for her performance.
Poker Face was met with critical acclaim upon release. The
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes reported a 98% approval rating for the first season based on 116 critic reviews. The website's critics consensus reads, "With the incomparable Natasha Lyonne as an ace up its sleeve,
Poker Face is a puzzle box of modest ambitions working with a full deck."
Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 84 out of 100 based on 44 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".
Chicago Sun-Timess
Richard Roeper gave a rating of 3.5 out of 4 stars and said, "The beauty part is watching the amazing Natasha Lyonne's Charlie puzzle out the crime in clever and often hilarious fashion."
Peter Travers of
ABC News felt Lyonne landed "the role of her career" in Charlie Cale and called
Poker Face "the best joyride of the 2023 TV season."
Linda Holmes of
NPR felt Lyonne's "unforgettable" performance proved herself to be the "
Peter Falk of her generation". Ben Travers of
IndieWire gave the series a B and stated "All this star power is enough to guarantee
Poker Face will be, at least, an enjoyable diversion. But... it's hard to shake the feeling that
Poker Face isn't as good as it could've been."
The Atlantics
Sophie Gilbert believed the show succeeded in its first episodes "by attending to the emotional cadences of overlooked people and places" but criticized the characters of later episodes for falling into
tropes.
Season 2 The second season also received critical acclaim. The review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes reported a 96% approval rating based on 77 critic reviews. The website's critics consensus states, "Instead of reshuffling its winning formula,
Poker Faces second season doubles down on the winning virtues of its predecessor and scores a jackpot." Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned a score of 79 out of 100 based on 26 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Empires David Opie awarded the second season with four out of five stars, stating, "The case-of-the-week format remains in place, mostly unchanged, but the serialised story that holds it together becomes more introspective and even existential, proving that the team's ambition isn't just limited to casting TV's most enviable guest list. If the impressive highs of Season 2 are anything to go by,
Poker Face could easily go on for ten more seasons and just get better each time. (No lies detected.)"
Consequences Liz Shannon Miller wrote, "It's all so thoughtfully written and executed, at times to the point of devastation, though Charlie remains the show's emotional anchor, keeping the audience from drifting into despair. So much of this show works simply because we just
like Charlie — and can see why other people like and trust her in a relatively short amount of time."
Accolades == Explanatory notes==