Chris Urankar from
InStyle magazine described the song as a "summery, radio-ready anthem", while
Take 40 Australia called it "an awesome party anthem!." A writer from MusicFix complimented "Pop a Bottle (Fill Me Up)" as a "fun weekend jam" and predicted the song to be another hit for Mauboy. Mike Wass from
Idolator wrote that the track "feels like an even better fit" for Mauboy than her previous single "
To the End of the Earth". Shayne of Flopstar Reviews described "Pop a Bottle (Fill Me Up)" as "a bland but pleasant jam" and felt that it was reminiscent of
One Direction and
Katy Perry's pop rock style. He also noted that the song's lyrics are not about sex "as the title suggests" and that it is "actually about how some guy is super nice" to Mauboy "and it makes her happy". "Pop a Bottle (Fill Me Up)" was nominated for "World's Best Song" at the
2014 World Music Awards. The song debuted and peaked at number two on the
ARIA Singles Chart dated 7 October 2013, and became Mauboy's sixth top-ten single. That same week, "Pop A Bottle (Fill Me Up)" debuted and peaked at number 33 on the
New Zealand Singles Chart, becoming Mauboy's highest-charting single in New Zealand. ==Music video==