Frank S. Nugent in
The New York Times wrote that the film is "one of the most engrossing and provocative films of the season"; according to him, "it's a thorough-going study in blacks and grays, without a free laugh in it; but it is also a remarkably beautiful motion picture from the purely pictorial standpoint and a strangely haunting drama. As a steady diet, of course, it would give us the
willies; for a change it's as tonic as a raw winter's day." At the time of its release, the film was widely criticized for being too negative about the State and moral character of the French. Over 60 years after its premiere, Lucy Sante, writing about the film for its DVD release by
Criterion Collection, called the film a "definitive example of the style known as '
poetic realism'. The ragged outlines, the lowdown settings, the romantic fatalism of the protagonists, the movement of the story first upward toward a single moment of happiness and then down to inexorable doom—the hallmarks of the style had germinated in some form or other through the decade, but in Marcel Carné's third feature they came together as archetypes." Danish director
Carl Dreyer included
Port of Shadows in his top 10 film list. A scene from the film is seen projected in the 2007
Academy Award-winning dramatization of
Ian McEwan's wartime tragic drama
Atonement. ==Home media==