The song received generally positive reviews.
Vibe's Preezy Brown ranked it third among the 18
Bully tracks, writing "Balancing tension and swagger, 'Preacher Man' is both engaging and effortless, demonstrating Ye's ability to fuse narrative wit with addictive rhythm." Peter A. Berry of
Complex stated the song "features a nice blend of charisma and cinema." Reviewing
Bully for
Slant Magazine, Paul Attard cited "Preacher Man" as among the tracks that are "ingeniously incorporating dusty soul samples and strong melodies", but are "so tidy that they can't help but read like West is punching well below his musical weight class." Eddy "Precise" Lamarre of
Rolling Out commented that the song's line ''This path I don't recommend
"lands because it feels honest." Jeff Ihaza of Rolling Stone'' remarked the song "takes Ye's flair for cinematics" and "fires on all cylinders." Aron A. of
HotNewHipHop opined that the song's production "made the album feel promising." Kieran Press-Reynolds of
Pitchfork highlighted the transition in the first passage from a voice resembling AI-generated vocals to a more natural-sounding voice, describing it as an "interesting effect", "Especially because it leads into some of the most traditionally cocksure Ye lyrics on
Bully".
Billboard's Michael Saponara placed it at number 11 in his ranking of the 18 songs from
Bully. == Personnel ==