Critical reaction The documentary received generally positive reviews by the press.
Metacritic gave
Prisoner of Paradise a score of 70 out of 100, based on 13 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Prisone of Paradise has an approval rating of 82% on
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, based on 28 reviews, and an average rating of 7.08/10.
Variety called the film "an important and smoothly mounted meditation on moral choices within the entertainment biz."
Charlotte Observer 's reviewer Lawrence Toppman praised the film, stating that "its uniqueness lies in its juxtaposition of happy faces and unhappy realities, of fleeting expressions of art and culture undone by daily brutality." The press widely agreed that the documentary exploited a new and unexpected aspect of the Nazi war against the Jews. According to
The Hollywood Reporter, the distinction between
Prisoner of Paradise and previous films of the same topic is that "it tells a morality tale of a man whose hubris partially led to his downfall and whose willingness to work for his Nazi overseers resulted in one of the most notorious propaganda films of the era." Along with the good reviews,
Prisoner of Paradise was mildly criticized for its analysis of why Gerron agreed to direct the
Nazi propaganda film of the camp.
The New York Times commented that the film "seems to just drift to a close rather than pronounce an end. This can be a result of wrestling with a daunting subject and not being up to its demands."
Nominations and awards The film received a nomination for Best Feature Documentary at the
75th Academy Awards. Director Malcolm Clarke won the Directors Guild of Canada Award. Clarke and
Stuart Sender were also nominated for the 2003 Directors Guild of America Award.
Prisoner of Paradise was joint winner (with
Storyville) of the Kodak Award for Best Documentary on Film in the 2003
Grierson Awards, ==References==