During its first years of existence, Progresista had a strong rivalry with
El Porvenir, a neighbor club from
Gerli. The football squad debuted in the
1922 season playing the official AFA championship after the association split into two bodies in
1919. Progresista played at the top level of Argentina until
1926 when AFA and dissident
AAmF merged. Therefore Progresista was relegated to
Segunda División along with
Alvear,
Argentino de Banfield,
Boca Alumni,
Del Plata, General San Martín,
Palermo,
Sportivo Balcarce,
Sportivo Dock Sud, Sportsman and Universal. After that, Progresista participated in the lower divisions of Argentine football, winning the 1935
Tercera División championship. Three years later, the club disaffiliated from the Association. ==Notable players==