Jason Okundaye of
The Guardian called
Protect Sarz at All Costs a "momentous, Black diaspora-surfing debut," writing that Sarz "lays a solid claim to the title of Nigeria’s most deft curator and enchanter of swinging hips." He described the album as "genre-fluid" and concluded that it "doesn’t mark an arrival, but an assertion of his prodigious talent." Abioye Samson of
Afrocritik stated that the album "radiates effortless joy" on tracks like "Happiness" and praised moments such as "Getting Paid" and "BMF," but concluded that as a full-length project it "rarely surprises or ignites the kind of thrill that makes the listening experience truly unforgettable," rating it 6.9/10. Adeayo Adebiyi of
Pulse Nigeria commended the album's production, writing that "with Sarz, the quality is in the fine lines" and that it "inspires superlative performances from the stars," rating the album 8.5/10. Chibuzo Emmanuel of the
Culture Custodian also praised Sarz' production on
Protect Sarz at All Costs, praising the blending of styles and chemistry between collaborators, yet adding that the album felt "more like a mixtape than the album it’s promoted as." Temiloluwa Adeyemo of
Digimillenials wrote that
Protect Sarz at All Costs felt like "both a victory lap and a reminder of [Sarz’s] legacy but also feels like a producer caught between statement and showcase." He concluded that while the album lacked direction, it was "more than a collection of collaborations, [it]'s a reminder of Sarz's unmatched touch and quiet dominance." Michael Kolawole of the
Lagos Review stated that the album showed that "the best way to protect Sarz is to allow him room to evolve." He concluded that the album was "a celebration of his influence and a declaration of his untouchable status". ==Track listing==