Experts' reactions Before the passage of the law, the
Israel Medical Association said medical ethics prohibited participation in executions. Yoav Sapir, a law professor who previously headed Israel's public defenders' office, said the bill discriminated against Palestinians since it would only apply to them.
B'Tselem,
Amnesty International and
Human Rights Watch said such discrimination amounted to
apartheid. In response to the law's adoption,
United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture Dr.
Alice Jill Edwards said that "[c]apital punishment is incompatible with human dignity and has no proven deterrent effect”.
Carolyn Hoyle (professor of criminology and director of the death penalty research unit at Oxford) and
Ron Dudai (criminology research associate at
Ben-Gurion University) argued that the death penalty is ineffective in general and against terrorism in particular, in an expert opinion submitted to the
Supreme Court of Israel. A statement by Israeli scholars of international law said the death penalty law was immoral, discriminated against Palestinians by effectively only applying to them, and violated both Israeli and international law. The UN
Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination said that the law "de facto appli[es] to Palestinians only" and was racially discriminatory.
Diplomatic reactions Joint statements condemning the law were issued by • Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt, Indonesia, Jordan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates; and • Australia, Germany, France, Italy, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. Separate statements condemning the law were made by China, Ireland, Canada, the
Palestinian Authority,
Hamas, the Council of Europe, and the European Union, which reminded Israel of its human rights obligations under the
EU–Israel Association Agreement.
Political reactions, protests and strikes On 31 March 2026, the
Israel Police violently dispersed protesters against the law in
West Jerusalem.
Haaretz reported that one photojournalist was injured. Five people were arrested in the protests. Internationally, protests against the law were reported in Germany,
Amsterdam, the Netherlands and in
Daraa, Syria, with videos of Syrian motorcyclists carrying the
Shahada flag while protesting against the law near an
Israeli checkpoint. Protests were held in
Ramallah,
Nablus and
Gaza City, 28 members of the British
House of Commons signed an
early day motion tabled mid-April stating the law "may amount to discriminatory treatment and contribute to a system of apartheid". On 22 April,
Petra Bayr, president of the
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, said the Israeli
Knesset's membership "might be suspended until there is a decision [against] or until it is clear that the law will not even go into force", and that the death penalty in general precluded membership. The
president of Israel,
Isaac Herzog, said the bill was "problematic" and asked how the bill would be implemented; according to a later statement, he was asking "sarcastically" about the law's requirement that court presidents and other officials should watch executions.
Media reactions Editorials in
The Guardian, Le Monde,
ABC, ''
, and Haaretz and columns in The Independent, Outlook, UnHerd, The Forward, Ynet, The Guardian
, The Globe and Mail, The Quint, the Middle East Eye, Arutz Sheva, The Jerusalem Post, and the Times of Israel'' condemned the law. Columnists in
The Jerusalem Post and
Jewish News Syndicate supported the death penalty.
Jewish groups' reactions In North America, the
Reform movement,
J Street,
Partners for Progressive Israel,
JSpace Canada and
T'ruah condemned the law, the
Conservative movement expressed reservations, the
Anti-Defamation League and
Jewish Federations of North America said they had no comment, and the
Zionist Organization of America supported the law. In Australia,
AIJAC and the
Zionist Federation opposed the law, and the
Executive Council of Australian Jewry expressed concerns that the law is a departure from Jewish principles. The
Board of Deputies of British Jews condemned the law. == Legal challenges ==