Puntigam played in her youth with
USV Gnas from 2000 until 2007, helping them win the Eastern under-13 division twice and the under-15 division once. She then played with
DFC LUV Graz in the
ÖFB Frauen Bundesliga from 2007 until 2009. Puntigam made her senior career debut in 2009 with
Bayern Munich II in the
2009–10 2. Frauen-Bundesliga. She scored three goals in 25 appearances, before joining the first team in 2010. In April 2014, Puntigam returned to Germany, joining
SC Freiburg alongside former Bayern Munich and SC Kriens teammate
Nicole Banecki. She scored four goals for Freiburg in 79 appearances. During her time at the French club, she contributed 10 goals and assists in 71 appearances. During the
2022–23 Frauen-Bundesliga season, she scored two goals in 21 league appearances, as well as playing three matches in the
DFB-Pokal. After leaving 1. FC Köln in July 2023, In September 2024, the club signed Puntigam to a two-year contract extension. ==International career==