On
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 21%, based on 14 reviews.
Owen Gleiberman summed up
Pure Luck in his D− review as, "a numbingly repetitive farce in which the cursed Short trips, walks into walls, trips, spills an entire saltshaker onto his breakfast, trips, sets people on fire, trips ..."
Roger Ebert gave the film one and a half stars, and zeroed in on the emptiness of much of the film's comedy:Consider, for example, the scene where Proctor and Campanella are in a Jeep that is teetering on the edge of a cliff, its rear wheels hanging in mid-air. We've seen situations like this many times before, but I can't remember one less compelling. It unspools without comic timing, it stops dead in the middle, the payoff isn't funny, and later we can see it wasn't even much of a cliff. Caryn James praised Martin Short's efforts in the film, which she found otherwise forgettable, "Against the odds, he makes
Pure Luck always painless and sometimes genuinely amusing. Martin Short can do anything, it seems, except find the right movies to star in."
Ongoing impact Around 5–7 years later, director Nadia Tass reported she was still receiving
residuals from the film because of its success in America. However, she said about the film:It was successful in a financial sense but not in a satisfying sense. It was congenial doing a Martin Short comedy, but American comedy is different from Australian comedy. It is broader. American audiences enjoyed
Pure Luck, but audiences in other countries did not enjoy it so much, with the exception of the Germans. I wanted to do something else with the comedy and so did Danny Glover. I would like to have put a lot more
pathos and pain into it. But they wanted a comedy for America. The cartoon series
Hey Arnold! (1996–2004) had a character, Eugene Horowitz, who is also a jinx and was likely based on Eugene Proctor from the film.
The Simpsons introduced a character named Frank Grimes in "
Homer's Enemy" who suffers a similar fate at the hands of the cosmically careless
Homer Simpson. In 2024,
Pure Luck was voted no. 2 in
IGN's "Top 10 Buddy Cop Movies of All Time". ==References==