Critics were positive towards the song. In the
Rolling Stone review of the album, critic Rob Sheffield wrote: "'God Put a Smile Upon Your Face' is the slinkiest and best thing Coldplay have ever done." Adrien Begrand of
PopMatters wrote: "Buckland's lead fills highlight the wondrous 'God Put a Smile on Your Face', as the song's chorus reaches heights that rival those of their fellow countrymen Doves." Ted Kessler of
NME wrote: "Over a pounding garage tattoo Martin poses a deep, mortality-based teaser ('where do we go from here?'), asserts some self-belief ('God gave me style, God gave me grace') and then hits upon the bottom line as the song's mood suddenly improves with another fat and glorious chorus: 'Yeah, when you work it out I'm the same as you....your guess is as good as mine'". "God Put a Smile upon Your Face" was featured in the band's first live album,
Live 2003. The song is available on
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock. The game also includes other Coldplay songs such as "
Yellow" and "
Violet Hill". The American TV series
Alias used it in the second-season episode "Double Agent", which aired on 2 February 2003.
Plan B sampled the track on his 2007
mixtape Paint it Blacker. The song was also covered by
Mark Ronson on his album
Version, which he performed live with
Adele at the
2008 Brit Awards. In 2010, "God Put a Smile upon Your Face" was included on the
The Xfm Top 1000 Songs of All Time book. == Music video ==