The strength of a person's accent can vary greatly all across Birmingham. As with most cities, the local accent changes relative to the area of the city in question. A common misconception is that everyone in Birmingham speaks the same accent. It could be argued that Brummie is an accent rather than a dialect as opposed to Black Country speech, which is a dialect with unique words and phrases, such as "owamya?" for
how are you, which, many comment, is not used in Brummie speech. Similarly, Brummies generally use the word
I while pronouncing it as 'oy', whereas Black Country natives instead use the dialectal term 'Ah', as in 'Ah bin', meaning
I have been. has said that the accent is "a dialectal hybrid of northern, southern,
Midlands,
Warwickshire,
Staffordshire and
Worcestershire speech", also with elements from the languages and dialects of its
Asian and
Afro-Caribbean communities. There are also differences between Brummie and
Black Country accents, which are not readily apparent to people from outside the West Midlands. A Black Country accent and a Birmingham accent can be hard to distinguish if neither accent is that broad. Phonetician
John Wells has admitted that he cannot tell any difference between the accents. Many historians and scholars argue that rhymes and vocabulary in the works of the Warwickshire native
William Shakespeare suggest that he used a local dialect in his work, either that of
Stratford-upon-Avon or, more broadly, a Brummie, Cotswold, Warwickshire, or other Midlands dialect. However, not all historians accept this argument, and Shakespeare's own accent will certainly have been distinct from any modern English one, including any of the Midlands today.
Stereotypes According to , among UK listeners "Birmingham English in previous academic studies and opinion polls consistently fares as the most disfavoured variety of British English, yet with no satisfying account of the dislike". He alleges that overseas visitors, in contrast, find it "lilting and melodious", and from this claims that such dislike is driven by various linguistic myths and social factors peculiar to the UK ("social
snobbery, negative media
stereotyping, the poor public image of the City of Birmingham, and the north/south geographical and linguistic divide"). For instance, despite the city's cultural and innovative history, its industrial background (as depicted by the
arm-and-hammer in
Birmingham's coat of arms) has led to a muscular and unintelligent stereotype: a "Brummagem screwdriver" is UK slang for a hammer. Thorne also cites the mass media and entertainment industry where actors, usually non-Birmingham, have used inaccurate accents and/or portrayed negative roles. Advertisements are another medium where many perceive stereotypes. Journalist Lydia Stockdale, writing in the
Birmingham Post, commented on advertisers' association of Birmingham accents with pigs: the pig in the ad for Colman's Potato Bakes,
Nick Park's
Hells Angel Pigs for
British Gas, the puppet simply known as Pig from
Pipkins and
ITV's "Dave the window-cleaner pig" all had Brummie accents. In 2003, a
Halifax bank advertisement featuring
Howard Brown, a Birmingham-born and based employee, was replaced by an animated version with an exaggerated comical accent overdubbed by a
Cockney actor. ==Pronunciation==