Put the Shine On received mixed reviews. Sasha Geffen of
Pitchfork gave the album a rating of 5.1 out of 10, describing it as an "incoherent melange" and "a return to their
maximalist tendencies, piling on drum machines,
chintzy
synthesizers, over-the-top raps, and
nu-metal guitars". The review stated that the album's "complicated tone... gets blunted in the record's production," and notes the use of "stock hip-hop beats", "clumsy
synth bass", "rhythmic elements", "
fuzz bass", "distorted
power chords", "harp loops", and lyrical content involving concepts like "generational trauma, mental illness, and sexual violence". ==Track listing==