Origins in Kentucky Baylor was briefly a member of the
Kentucky House of Representatives from 1819 to 1820, before he resigned and moved to Alabama. He had offered himself for the Kentucky Legislature in place of his older brother
George, who was stepping down. He played the violin or fiddle along with his opponent,
Robert P. Letcher, to attract voters, later claiming a narrow victory.
Alabama representative After a single term in office in Kentucky, Baylor left and abruptly moved to Alabama. Some have attributed the sudden move to grief. A persistent story says that while he was riding with a young woman he intended to marry, she was bucked off her horse and dragged to her death, with Baylor unable to save her. Finding the familiar scenes of Kentucky too painful to endure, he left for
Tuscaloosa, Alabama. Once there, Baylor began to practice law and later continued his political career. Baylor converted and was ordained a Baptist minister in 1839. In August 1840, Baylor was a participant of the
Battle of Plum Creek, serving under
Edward Burleson along with two other Baptist ministers,
Z. N. Morrell and
Thomas Washington Cox. He quickly made a name for himself in Texas law as judge of the Third Judicial District of the Congress of the Republic of Texas, and was appointed to the
Supreme Court of the Republic of Texas as an associate justice in 1841, a position he would hold until the
annexation of Texas in 1845. and in 1844, along with
William M. Tryon and Rev.
James Huckins, sent a petition to the
Congress of the Republic of Texas asking the nation to charter a Baptist university. In response to this petition, The Republic of Texas produced an Act of Congress that was signed on February 1, 1845, by
Anson Jones, providing the charter that yielded
Baylor University and, later, the
University of Mary Hardin-Baylor. Baylor presided over the meeting that named
Henry Lee Graves as the first president of Baylor University. The Texas
Temperance Society elected Baylor as its first president in 1845. He was one of two delegates, along with
James S. Mayfield, elected to represent
Fayette County at the
Texas Constitutional Convention of 1845. At the convention he advocated for homestead protection, the forbiddance of ministers from legislative service, a system of judicial appointment and fought strongly against judicial elections. On April 16, 1846, Baylor was appointed to a six-year term as judge of the state's Third Judicial District. He was confirmed by the senate without a dissenting vote, although senator
Jesse Grimes tried to lay the nomination on the table and did not vote in the confirmation. Baylor, later the same year, entered the running in the first election for the state's
2nd congressional district, finishing last out of four candidates, with the seat won by
Timothy Pilsbury. Initially successful in his effort against judicial elections, the greatest change in his career occurred in 1850 when, by constitutional amendment, the appointment system was replaced in favor of popular judicial elections. He held the judicial position until his retirement in 1863. == Later life and legacy ==