Orlando Pride Portland Thorns FC selected Hill with the 14th pick in the
2017 NWSL College Draft and subsequently traded her to the
Orlando Pride in exchange for first- and fourth-round picks in the
2018 NWSL College Draft. and she earned her first start on June 3. Hill scored her first professional goal on June 28, 2017, a game-winner against
Sky Blue FC. She finished her rookie season with three goals, one assist from only 14 games, 8 of which were starts. After her contract option exercised for 2018, Hill went on to play 21 games in 2018, but a nagging injury lead to her starting only seven of them. She scored four goals tying
Marta as third best for the Pride. Hill had a new contract offer given at the end of the 2018 season.
Perth Glory (loan) On October 19, 2017, Hill joined Australian club
Perth Glory on loan for the
2017–18 W-League season. During her first season at Perth she finished with 9 goals, the third-most goals in the league and 6 assists, the most assists in the league. She re-signed a loan agreement for
2018–2019 and ended the season with a further 6 goals as the team finished runners up in the Grand Final. With the season disrupted by the
COVID-19 pandemic, Hill eventually made her Red Stars debut during the
2020 NWSL Challenge Cup. Hill scored the lone goal for Chicago in the 2021 NWSL Championship Match losing to the Washington Spirit 2-1. Hill completed her time with the team in 2022.
Linköpings FC (loan) In August 2020, Hill joined Swedish
Damallsvenskan club
Linköpings FC on loan.
San Diego Wave On December 2, 2022, Hill was signed in free agency by
San Diego Wave FC. The Wave signed Hill to a two-year contract running through the
2024 season. Hill made her first appearance for the club on April 15, 2023, playing in a 0-1 defeat to the
OL Reign. Hill entered the match as a substitute for
Jaedyn Shaw, coming on in the 87th minute of the game. She also earned a yellow card in her debut. Hill ended up playing in 18 regular season matches for the Wave and the team won the 2023 NWSL Shield with the best regular season record.
Bay FC Hill was selected by
Bay FC with the 5th overall pick in the
2024 NWSL expansion draft. She made her debut for the Californian club in Bay FC's first-ever game, a 1-0 victory over
Angel City FC.
Racing Louisville On December 23, 2025, Hill was announced to have signed a two-year contract with
Racing Louisville FC. ==International career==