Spain's corsair Juan de Alarcón stealthily approached to New Providence with a commission issued by Governor José Fernández de Córdoba and a pair of
barcos luengos carrying 200 men. Having seized a woodcutting sloop off the island of Andros, Alarcón compelled its master William Bell to pilot in via the eastern channel. At daybreak Alarcón disembarked 150 men within a half-mile outside Charles Town (later Nassau), while his corsair ships bore down upon the six vessels anchored in its harbour. Charles Town's population consisted of approximately 400 free men capable of bearing arms, perhaps 200 free women, a like number of children, and 200 enslaved people. Taken utterly by surprise, they were incapable of mounting an effective defense. Former governor Robert Clarke was wounded and captured as he attempted to mount a feeble countercharge, while his recently arrived successor Robert Lilburne fled from his bedroom in the
Wheel of Fortune, along with most other residents.
John Oldmixon claimed that Clarke died being roasted on a spit after the Spaniards had captured him. After leaving Charles Town Alarcón hastened across to northern Eleuthera and visited a like treatment upon its English settlement, before returning to Charles Town on 15 November 1684 (O.S.) to set fire on its buildings and carry off numerous residents to
Havana. The Bahamas subsequently remained devoid of any recognizable English presence until December 1686, when a small contingent from
Jamaica under the preacher Thomas Bridges reoccupied New Providence Island, where more colonists gradually joined them. ==Aftermath==