2004 election In 2004, Kuhl ran for the House seat of retiring U.S. Representative
Amo Houghton, a Republican multimillionaire who had displayed a moderate bent during 18 years in Washington. In the Republican primary, Kuhl, who was supported by Houghton, defeated
Monroe County Legislator Mark Assini. He then defeated 27-year-old Democrat
Samara Barend in the general election. In September 2006, Kuhl welcomed Vice President
Dick Cheney to a major fundraiser in Rochester. Kuhl agreed with Cheney's assessment that combating terrorists around the world was the top issue in the campaign. According to Kuhl, bad news from the war zone should be countered by a frank discussion of reality. Regarding his Finger Lakes and Southern Tier constituents, Kuhl said, "They don't necessarily understand the full importance of our presence there". Preliminary results from the November election showed Kuhl narrowly beating Massa by a margin of approximately 5,600 votes (out of about 193,000 cast). Massa had initially refused to concede the election and was expected to file a challenge, but on November 15, 2006, Massa conceded the election and contacted Kuhl to congratulate him. According to the final election results, which were certified by the New York State Board of Elections on December 14, 2006, Kuhl won by a margin of 6,033 votes (out of 206,121 cast).
2008 election Kuhl's again faced Democratic nominee and former Navy officer
Eric Massa, losing the rematch by a narrow 51%-49% margin, roughly reversing the outcome of the 2006 elections. Kuhl finished behind Massa in
Cattaraugus County, a county Kuhl carried by a 56%-44% margin in 2006 (and one that voted for presidential candidate
John McCain in 2008), likely contributing to the loss. Because the race was so close, Kuhl did not concede the election until November 21, 2008.
Political positions Kuhl was considered a fairly reliable conservative who generally voted against
abortion rights,
gun control and tax increases. He was, however, a member of the
Republican Main Street Partnership. Kuhl supported making then-President Bush's tax cuts permanent. In addition, he also advocated for a 10-cent reduction in federal gasoline taxes. In September 2007, Kuhl was noted in the news as being one of the most outspoken opponents of a plan by then-New York Governor
Eliot Spitzer to allow illegal aliens to apply for driver's licenses. He also became a prominent opponent of the
SCHIP expansion, a stance for which he earned significant animosity from various groups including
MoveOn, the
Service Employees International Union, and even former New York Governor
Eliot Spitzer. During his time as a state senator, Kuhl was an advocate of
New York City secession and unsuccessfully introduced several bills to separate
Upstate New York from downstate. == Federal electoral results ==